I purchased the Rachel Zoe's BOS so I received my own rings, but I swapped one ring for a different color with another swapper. Now the one I swapped for has tarnished -- go figure. I know this is absolutely not the swapper's fault since the ring was perfect when it was sent to me. I got the email from BOS about the rings, do you think they would replace this one if I explain the situation? Only problem is that it's not my original ring, so it's a different color.
Btw - are all colors tarnished? The silver/white gold one I have is the one that changed.